Teach Our Children Well
Sunday Cuppa

Health Care And Poverty: We Are Failing Our Most Vulnerable

As a nation, we are failing the most vulnerable members of our society.

The number of homeless schoolchildren, uprooted amidst the financial turmoil of the last few years is rising:

There were 679,000 homeless students reported in 2006-7, a total that surpassed one million by last spring, Ms. Duffield said.

With schools just returning to session, initial reports point to further rises. In San Antonio, for example, the district has enrolled 1,000 homeless students in the first two weeks of school, twice as many as at the same point last year.

Between foreclosures, job losses and catastrophic illness costs, it’s not just the very poor who are feeling the pinch. The middle class is hurting, too, as families who never had to ask for assistance in the past suddenly depend on it just to get by from week to week.

These days? We’re all a paycheck away from disaster, it seems.

And the elderly? New analysis shows that the poverty rate among those over 65 is far worse than previously thought:

Nearly 20% of Americans over 65 would be considered poor if the government updates the way it calculates poverty, which hasn’t considered medical costs, regional variations and other factors since its creation in 1955.

Currently, the poverty rate for that age group is 9.7%, or 3.6 million people. If the government adopts a revised formula by the National Academy of Sciences, that figure would jump to 18.6% — 6.8 million people…

Recently, a United Way group in Illinois tried to give its volunteers a glimpse into life for the "other half." The lessons learned were some hard ones:

Participants were separated into six different low-income family types and assigned a role to play under various situations, including being newly unemployed, a new applicant for government assistance or a part-time employee relying on food stamps.

Families had to keep their home secure, pay their bills, feed their families and keep the utilities on for a month using various income and debt scenarios. Services such as an employment office, pawn shop, banker, food pantry and grocery store were available. To reach them, though, every person had to use a $2 transportation voucher, which grew scarce as money ran low.

If you have never had to face unexpected poverty, or didn’t grow up around it as a child, then these situations might sound dire. For folks who have lived barely scraping by? It sounds like a whole lot of life.

Certainly personal responsibility plays a big role: bad choices make for bad results for a lot of folks. But for young kids who didn’t choose the families into which they were born? Or for the elderly who have seen retirement savings shrink over the past few years while prescription doughnut holes have expanded?

Who wants to tell their grandma the fact she has to choose between her medicine and food is her own damned fault and to stop whining about prescription drug profit margins.

There is a Kathy Mattea song that I love called "Seeds," where she says that we’re all just seeds in God’s hands — we start the same, but some of us land on fertile soil and some of us get sand at the start. Compassionate people understand it from the get go.

Would that everyone did, because we are failing those who are most vulnerable in this country.

  Spotlight
68 Responses to "Health Care And Poverty: We Are Failing Our Most Vulnerable"
sadlyyes | Monday September 7, 2009 06:12 am 1

im weeping…wonder what Tom Ridge thinks


barbara | Monday September 7, 2009 06:14 am 2

This is heartbreaking stuff, Christy. For the children, the seniors, for everyone who is “a paycheck away from disaster.” Oh, wait. That’s everyone. Children, seniors, black people, brown people, poor people. Pretty much everyone but independently wealthy white people. The GOP doesn’t care. Pass it on.


barbara | Monday September 7, 2009 06:22 am 3

BTW, in case you missed it, Social Security recipients will receive no COLA increases for the next two years, making a bad situation worse.


PriscillaQOB | Monday September 7, 2009 06:26 am 4

Christy, thanks so much for highlighting this!

When my school started 2 weeks ago, I was prepared. I buy supplies beforehand for all the kids. Good thing I did — out of 22 students only 6 were able to buy the small list of 5 things that I asked for. We also found a retirement community that helped us out with supplies this year. The church across the street helps too but this year too many of their own members are in poverty and they weren’t able to do as much as they have in the past.

And I always make sure to keep a few dollars in my pocket for lunches. Until the paperwork is processed even the homeless kids have to pay for breakfast and lunch. I won’t let any of my students go hungry or have to accept the lower quality choice for those without money.

In the past I have has students who lived in cars, many live in residential motels with large families in 1 room. Some live with relatives who are barely able to keep their own families afloat.

No child deserves to be hungry yet many of the children eat the 2 meals a day at school and nothing else. We are working on a program to provide weekend family care packages but it is very hard with the food banks overwhelmed.

No child should have to sleep in fear and discomfort with vermin and insects attacking them yet many, many at our school do. Our district’s homeless services tries their best to help but with budget cuts and personnel cuts it becomes harder every day.

I urge all people of goodwill to check with your local school district or senior center and see if there is one person or family you could help out a little. Donating used uniforms can be very helpful. Even if you can only pick up a two-for-one deal at the supermarket and share one it means one less hungry person for one meal.

We are all in this together, whether we realize it or not.


barbara | Monday September 7, 2009 06:27 am 5
In response to PriscillaQOB @ 4

You are an angel, ma’am.


SouthernDragon | Monday September 7, 2009 06:29 am 6

Mornin’, Christy, pups.

Slept in and didn’t realize how far behind I was afore I got started.

Would it be too much to ask of our government to use figures that reflect reality instead of the Village’s voodoo world view?

What does it say that a man on death row has more insight than all the corporate media mouthpieces put together.

Guess I’m just gonna start bein’ gnarly about this shit.


SouthernDragon | Monday September 7, 2009 06:35 am 7
In response to PriscillaQOB @ 4

You are a wonderful person.


OldCoastie | Monday September 7, 2009 06:35 am 8
In response to barbara @ 3

absolutely disastrous for many… I can’t believe there is no COLA!

hard to believe the Democrats are in charge…


tjbs | Monday September 7, 2009 06:36 am 9

Morning Christy and Happy labor day to those who labor.

Heroin addicts and crack addicts will destroy their lives and their families and then the surrounding communities with their self destruction.
We are addicted to war and militarism as a country. Since 1948 we have spent a total ,up to 2004, of $15 TRILLION to build up the military. Sounds close to the national debt doesn’t it? There’s a military base or factory in every congressional district for a reason. Look at the combined military /intelligence/homeland security budget that again we will borrow from foreigners to find the reason for our unending woes. But don’t you feel “safe”?


druidity36 | Monday September 7, 2009 06:36 am 10

Barbara Ehrenreich has been talking about this for years. When i first read “Nickel and Dimed”, it felt like a bell tolling. Thank you for talking about poverty. If there’s one thing that Edwards would have contributed to this current world triage, is a focus on highlighting and lessening Poverty. Sadly, his opportunity to affect the dialogue has become forestalled. His own doing, of course. I’m not sure how much this issue will become part of the national discourse, but personally, i think it’s where the talk should BEGIN.

This Labor day i am thankful to say after 13 weeks on the Unemployment rolls, i will be starting a new job on Thursday. Kitchen work, but it’s a job.

Cheers all.


bob5540 | Monday September 7, 2009 06:38 am 11

No guts, no glory. (Steal and repost)


barbara | Monday September 7, 2009 06:40 am 12
In response to druidity36 @ 10

So happy for you! It’s a start back. Yay.


wayne49 | Monday September 7, 2009 06:40 am 13

Last night on C-Span Q&A an interview with T.R. Reid, Author, “The Healing of America: A Quest for Better, Cheaper, and Fairer Health Care”. He will be here for a book salon in October. One of his major points is that other countries first decided that health care for all is a moral imperative and they found a way to make it happen. Really good stuff.


SouthernDragon | Monday September 7, 2009 06:41 am 14

30 years ago I worked at a crisis center in Corvallis, OR. Among other services we had 2 grocery stores in town that accepted our vouchers. There weren’t many homeless in the area but many seniors who were, shall we say, stretched financially. I couldn’t help but wonder if my “golden” years were going to be similar. Now that I’m 65 I’m beginning to see the answer.


PriscillaQOB | Monday September 7, 2009 06:41 am 15
In response to druidity36 @ 10

druidity36, congratulations on the job! My kids’ parents all work. They just don’t make enough money to pay rent, utilities, transportation, and everything else. Medical care is almost always out of the question unless they have SCHIP and even then providers are scarce and hard to get to for treatment, not to mention getting off work without being fired to travel to an appointment.

I am so angry that Wall Street banksters will be receiving millions of dollars in bonuses while a little boy in my class had a birthday last week and didn’t get a cake or a present because they couldn’t afford it. They had a meal and sang and I made a big deal of it at school. This happens all too often in the “greatest, richest country in the world.”


ShotoJamf | Monday September 7, 2009 06:41 am 16

Good morning, FDLers:

This stuff is just awful, and the fact that the “financial services industry” was awarded $Trillions in the face of this reality only serves to further clarify the priorities extant.

On a related note, Taibbi’s piece on the healthcare fiasco has now hit The Worldwide Interwebs Machine. What a read. Go here:

http://www.rollingstone.com/po….._and_wrong


SouthernDragon | Monday September 7, 2009 06:45 am 17
In response to ShotoJamf @ 16

The opening paragraph alone should have BCBS calling its attorneys.

Let’s start with the obvious: America has not only the worst but the dumbest health care system in the developed world. It’s become a black leprosy eating away at the American experiment — a bureaucracy so insipid and mean and illogical that even our darkest criminal minds wouldn’t be equal to dreaming it up on purpose.


Prairie Sunshine | Monday September 7, 2009 06:46 am 18

Maybe that United Way group could do the same for members of the U.S. Senate. If Grassley and Co. could tear themselves away from their Florida fatcat fundraising parties, that is.

Where is the Iowa ground game to bring it to Grassley…and his voters?


RevBev | Monday September 7, 2009 06:47 am 19

These pictures are so poignant. Taking care of the “least of these” is literal Scripture: take care of the poor, the widows, the orphans….both Hebrew Bible prophets and New Testament. You would think this would be a very bi-partisan goal for liberals and fundmentalists. There is a strong voice from Compolo and Jim Wallis, but not, it seems, many very Biblical conservatives That contradiction has always been hard for me.

The view of the prophets was that our focus was on the community, the larger group, as a responsibility beyond taking care of ourselves. There is strong Bible language for God’s “preferential treatment of the poor”, all that liberation theology that caused Rev Wright + Obama so much trouble.

How sad….doing for the least of these is a huge theme…As you did unto them, you did unto me, the Word says.


druidity36 | Monday September 7, 2009 06:51 am 20
In response to PriscillaQOB @ 15

I am eminently grateful that not only is my wife beautiful, but she’s wicked smart and works in a growing industry (Green building). She has OK healthcare through her job. Strangely enough, we must be one of the 2% of people the Massachusetts plan works for, bc the State pays the lions share of our costs. Still hoping for a Single Payer system, but know that’s unlikely. Wasn’t Rep Weiner gonna have Single Payer scored? Did that ever happen?

Got a box of #2 Peaches. Gonna be doing some jamming today!


JimWhite | Monday September 7, 2009 06:53 am 21

Good morning, Christy

It’s just so sad and angering that there is just no compassion for those whose lives have been destroyed by the over-arching greed that has destroyed our economy and our social structure. I’m pretty sure I’ve posted on this before, but this conversation seems a good place to bring out the lyrics of a country song that just send me over the top with anger.

The set up is that the singer got a call from a friend’s wife, saying the friend has fallen off the wagon. The singer goes to the bar and finds his friend:

I say hey man, what’s going on
He said I don’t know where to start

Sarah’s old car’s about to fall apart
And the washer quit last week
We had to put momma in the nursing home
And the baby’s cutting teeth
I didn’t get much work this week
And I got bills to pay

So how does the singer respond? Does he offer to help out a friend who is in a tight spot? Does he recommend a job he knows where the friend can get more work?

No. He tells the friend (and through him, all of us) to just suck it up:

I said I know this ain’t what you wanna hear
But it’s what I’m gonna say

(Chorus)
Sounds like life to me it ain’t no fantasy
It’s just a common case of everyday reality
Man I know it’s tough but you gotta suck it up
To hear you talk you’re caught up in some tragedy
It sounds like life to me

No, the song says, just get used to it. We aren’t supposed to have much and “everyday reality” says we just have to deal with it. This song makes me want to throw a brick through the radio.


barbara | Monday September 7, 2009 07:05 am 22
In response to SouthernDragon @ 14

More sobering than AA, isn’t it?!


i4u2bi | Monday September 7, 2009 07:06 am 23

What human characteristic flaw make us care about the poor, the weak, the old, the infirm and yes children? Can’t we just take a pill that causes us to forget about these people. How is that Conservatives already have conqeured this geneic flaw? Maybe we could get them to tell us their secret?


TexasReader | Monday September 7, 2009 07:11 am 24

HR 3200 will calculate the cost/life years for spending money on the elderly. They will only be a calculation not a person. End of life counseling will be provided by Medicare.
Medicare is slated to be cut by $1.4 trillion in 2010 by lowering reimbursements to cardiologists and oncologists. That is truly compassion since those are two of the specialties that older people use the most. I am a 61 year old cancer patient and my wife is the same age and is a heart patient. We expect great compassion when we go on Medicaid – RIGHT.
I just spend a week with my 94 year old Dad. His doctor talked to him, my brother and me about a plan. No expensive tests were ordered for his pneumonia because any results obtained could only be cured by invasive surgery that would kill him. We all agreed to put him on a DNR status. The doctor did not charge us for his time and advice, no bureaucrat had to approve our decisions, and we are all at peace with our decisions.
Keep the government out of heart wrenching family decisions and let them perform their assigned duties as limited by the Constitution.


barbara | Monday September 7, 2009 07:11 am 25
In response to JimWhite @ 21

Preamble to the Republican little red book:

If you don’t see it, you don’t have to deal with it. Ergo, wear blinders and shades, don’t read (only batshit crazy liberals can write), watch Fox and above all else, do not get sucked into thinking.


jayt | Monday September 7, 2009 07:13 am 26
In response to i4u2bi @ 23

What human characteristic flaw make us care about the poor, the weak, the old, the infirm and yes children?

The “human decency” gene?

How is that Conservatives already have conquered this genetic flaw?

liquefied $100 bills, sucked up into a syringe, and jabbed right in their fucking eyeballs.


jayt | Monday September 7, 2009 07:15 am 27
In response to barbara @ 25

…do not get sucked into thinking.

because their thinking sucks.


RevBev | Monday September 7, 2009 07:15 am 28
In response to TexasReader @ 24

I think that is all that is called for in the draft; a conversation does not = bureaucratic input. That’s what so misleading about all the “death panel” fuss. Just inaccurate scare language.


barbara | Monday September 7, 2009 07:18 am 29
In response to jayt @ 27

Not sure. By and large, Republicans seem to have read-only discs. Press button, spew rhetoric, replay. Cannot write over what’s there. No thought required.


i4u2bi | Monday September 7, 2009 07:21 am 30
In response to jayt @ 26

These are absolutely great answers..and I welcome more input. We need to get to the bottom of this.


sadlyyes | Monday September 7, 2009 07:23 am 31
In response to i4u2bi @ 23

animals,and the whole freakin planet too


sadlyyes | Monday September 7, 2009 07:27 am 32

i might write a diary

but for now

my termfor the PUBLIC OPTION is

ALL-AMERICA-CARE

signup…IF ya like it


SouthernDragon | Monday September 7, 2009 07:28 am 33

From Taibbi’s RS piece.

Everyone knows this, including the president. Last spring, when he met with Rep. Lynn Woolsey, the co-chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, Obama openly said so. “He said if he were starting from scratch, he would have a single-payer system,” says Woolsey. “But he thought it wasn’t possible, because it would disrupt the health care industry.”

My emphasis.

It wasn’t the “health care industry” that would have been disrupted so much as it was the “health insurance industry.” Physicians, clinics and hospitals that made money per procedure would have seen less dollars but that’s a good thing.


pluege | Monday September 7, 2009 07:30 am 34

as pressing as is the need to get assistance to the disadvantaged, its not the most pressing problem. The most pressing problem is that a substantial portion of the of the population don’t care, and that the national dialogue is under the control of plutocrats who believe they are superior in every way and deserving of the advantages they bestow upon themselves and riches they hoard. Maintaining a large and growing underclass of suffering validates their superiority. Eliminate the underclass and their delusion of superiority evaporates.

Poverty, poor education, unfordable health care , these are symptoms, they are not the disease. The disease is the plutocracy that does not for a second buy into the notion of community, of equality and opportunity for all. Just the opposite, they believe in social Darwinism and apply all their advantage to maintain their status at the top.


foothillsmike | Monday September 7, 2009 07:31 am 35
In response to SouthernDragon @ 33

So instead of health care reform what we get is wealth care.


twolf1 | Monday September 7, 2009 07:31 am 36

PJEvans | Monday September 7, 2009 07:31 am 37

What human characteristic flaw make us care about the poor, the weak, the old, the infirm and yes children? Can’t we just take a pill that causes us to forget about these people. How is that Conservatives already have conqeured this geneic flaw? Maybe we could get them to tell us their secret?

Maybe it’s the conservatives that have the genetic defect: no empathy, not much sympathy, and no way to get them.


i4u2bi | Monday September 7, 2009 07:33 am 38
In response to sadlyyes @ 32

Me likey!


foothillsmike | Monday September 7, 2009 07:34 am 39
In response to PJEvans @ 37

Conservatives – the people humanity left behind.


mlmc | Monday September 7, 2009 07:34 am 40

I have to ask myself: which is worse – voting for Bush because you’d like to have a beer with him or voting for Obama because you like listening to his speeches.

The issues are so dire now that only a great leader could turn the situation around. Instead we voted for an unknown by a landslide and he is turning out to be merely mediocre.


barbara | Monday September 7, 2009 07:34 am 41

My brother (an adult with mental retardation) receives SS and MA benefits.

He works under the auspices of a service provider organization in the community. He used to earn nearly $7/hour at his warehouse job. Provider and/or employer revamped payment structure. Brother now earns piece-rate, and the bulk of his work is paid at $2/hour or less. He loves his job and does not understand that he’s being shafted.

Shafted, you say? No. “He’s darn lucky he has a job at all.” Probably some truth there, but where is the justice in this?

SS with no COLA increase for two years.

MA (via the state) that has just decided in its infinite wisdom to save money by limiting recipients to one dental cleaning/check-up per year. This in a population where dental hygiene is a severe problem, leading to gum disease and linked medically to other disease that can spring from rotting teeth and gums.

I am trying to bridge the gaps (so to speak) for this man who has worked as hard as he is able, every single day; gets absolutely stellar job ratings from his supervisor; and who, for all practical purposes, is living in poverty.

It burns.


ShotoJamf | Monday September 7, 2009 07:34 am 42
In response to SouthernDragon @ 33

The piece is a pretty good read, eh? I’ve been sending it around, even to a few friends who are…um…of the Wingnut Persuasion. If they can get past the first few paragraphs, they just dig right in.

I’m so boneheaded that I just keep trying. If I’ve gotta go down, then I intend to go down swinging…


SouthernDragon | Monday September 7, 2009 07:38 am 43
In response to foothillsmike @ 35

Nothing new there.

Nothing to see here, move along.


sadlyyes | Monday September 7, 2009 07:39 am 44

Thurman James — World News Trust

Sept. 2, 2009 — The power to create and issue money ought to be the sole dominion of government and should never reside in the hands of private institutions, but today all new money created in the United States comes into being in the form of loans from corporate banks, not the U.S. Treasury.

One of the major effects of this method of money creation is that enormous wealth ends up under the control of a tiny minority of the people, and those who wield such power get to determine where the money goes and what projects get funded (or opposed).

The U.S. fractional reserve banking system generates new money by allowing private banks to make interest bearing loans to consumers, corporations, and governments; creating money from the ether with only a few strokes of a keyboard. All new money in our economy comes into existence in the form of interest bearing debt.

Only the federal government has the constitutional authority to create money and spend it into circulation without inflationary results. Fractional reserve banking destroys democratic institutions because private banks create money which is then loaned to the government at interest, creating inflation as soon it is enters the marketplace.

According to Stephen Zarlenga, director of the American Monetary Institute, the path to monetary reform is threefold and each change must be enacted simultaneously to work.

more

http://worldnewstrust.com/comp…..90/…


SouthernDragon | Monday September 7, 2009 07:40 am 45
In response to ShotoJamf @ 42

I’m so boneheaded that I just keep trying

Welcome to the club.

They can kill me but they can’t eat me.


SouthernDragon | Monday September 7, 2009 07:41 am 46
In response to sadlyyes @ 44

One definitely gets this idea reading Les Leopold’s The Looting of America.


Liberaldominion | Monday September 7, 2009 07:43 am 47

I’m disenchanted with the administration’s apparent refusal to take off the gloves and get tough — for the sake of the American public.

Bi-partisanship and accommodation will not work. “You can’t be rational with an irrational person [or party]”.

http://www.WhiteHouseBalls.com


sadlyyes | Monday September 7, 2009 07:47 am 48
In response to SouthernDragon @ 46

your such a voracious reader,i marvel!!

youre a keeper SD

bought a puppy for a 10 yr.oldboy at our local shelter will post pics,and NEW VIDEO at the site…hopefully this weekend


300SDL | Monday September 7, 2009 07:58 am 49
In response to PriscillaQOB @ 15

‘It is not given to us to right every wrong, to make perfect all the imperfections of the world. But neither is it given to us to sit content in our storehouses dieting while others starve, buying 8 million new cars a year while most of the world goes without shoes. We are simply not doing enough.

“Our lives on this planet are too short, the work to be done too great. But perhaps we can remember that those who live with us are our brothers, that they share with us the same short moment of life that they seek as do we, nothing but the chance to live out their ives in purpose and happiness, surely this bond of common fate, this bond of common roles can begin to teach us something, that we can begin to work a little harder, to become in our hearts brothers and countrymen once again.”

Robert F. Kennedy, genuine human being

And you are right Southern Dragon, this is more sobering than AA. How sad it is that these poverty issues are more often than not just an inconvenient afterthought by our MSM who would rather concentrate on their soap operatic trivia and tearing down the redemptive things people of good will seek to build.

We must keep the spirit of RFK alive by continuing to advocate for the least of us, so that one day, we may have the equity and justice that we all seek.


oldtree | Monday September 7, 2009 08:09 am 50

After all these years, isn’t it obvious that this is how we “care” for people? In music, we talk about a song having soul. It isn’t a nebulous term to describe some view of omnipotence and redemption, it is a term of fact. It means it works, it has the guts. It turns, it wiggles and it drives.
We do not have any soul as a country.


OldCoastie | Monday September 7, 2009 08:09 am 51

how is we keep blaming the Republicans for all this mess when the Dems are in charge?

yes, they are contributing severely to the problem, but just who is in charge here?

I’m just disgusted with the lot of ‘em!


sadlyyes | Monday September 7, 2009 08:24 am 52
In response to OldCoastie @ 51

all sold to the oligarchy


Lea (no uh) | Monday September 7, 2009 08:39 am 53

One of the saddest parts is that all of these homeless children, whose lives have been turned upside down, inside out and backwards, will still be expected to take and do well on The Tests. Failure to do so could result in the child being retained in grade and severe sanctions for the school.

Compassionate, no?

As a teacher in California, I am not allowed to require my students to bring in supplies. This year the school provided me a pencil, a 16-count box of crayons, and a bottle of glue for each student. I bought everything else, necessary if I want my class to run like I want it to run. Careful scouring of Target and Staples kept the bill as low as possible, but it was still a pretty big chunk of change. Then the district cuts 4 work days off my calendar (2% paycut) and my health insurance premium increases by $184 a month (another 2% paycut). Lots of new requirements this year because we’re now Program Improvement because we didn’t make it over the ever-increasing bar of AYP. It’s like They’re doing everything they can to take all of the joy out of teaching.


pluege | Monday September 7, 2009 08:51 am 54
In response to PJEvans @ 37

Maybe it’s the conservatives that have the genetic defect: no empathy, not much sympathy, and no way to get them.

exactly right. The salient/dominant feature of republicans/conservatives is that they are completely devoid of empathy. As a result they are fully and completely left in a world of fear, insecurity, and self-absorption rendering them psychotically, violently sick individuals. If the damage they do wasn’t so atrocious, you’d have to feel sorry for them – its an ugly, ugly world their minds inhibit.


PriscillaQOB | Monday September 7, 2009 08:59 am 55
In response to Lea (no uh) @ 53

I’m with you Lea (no uh). We are on the last year of “safe harbor” at my school as far as AYP goes. We missed by 5 points last year. My state requires a 12% jump each year.

Out of the original 23 students I started the year with, only 15 were there to take the test. By the last day of school there were only 9 left. The 14 new students that replaced them had attended 2 – 4 other schools throughout the year due to frequent moves. I was held accountable for all, even the students whom I had not taught for more than 2 weeks.

I know WalMart is evil but if it weren’t for the quarter a box crayons, the fifty cent notebooks, the one dollar boxes of markers and the five cent folders I wouldn’t have much of anything to teach with or use. I still spent about $1000 on supplies. I work a second job in the summer and save that money to buy supplies that my school can’t afford, things like primary lined paper, composition books, etc.

At the end of this year I may be fired if our school doesn’t up the test scores enough, all with Arne Duncan and Obama’s blessing. Teaching is fast becoming a no-win profession if you choose to work with poor children in America. When Arne fired the teachers in Chicago schools and brought in “better” teachers, their scores actually went down 3 years straight. But the law is the law, right?


300SDL | Monday September 7, 2009 09:03 am 56
In response to PriscillaQOB @ 55

Don’t ever give up—nothing worthwhile is easy. We’re all pulling for you!


PriscillaQOB | Monday September 7, 2009 09:06 am 57
In response to 300SDL @ 56

Thank you, from the bottom of my heart! You actually brought a tear to my eye — it’s rare to hear praise for teachers nowadays. I won’t give up. I’ve worked at this school for a decade and it’s like a family. I teach whole families of children as they enter school; this year I have 9 kids whose brothers and sisters were my former students. Leaving would be very hard but as a wise teacher in NYC once told me “there are children everywhere who need us.” I will go on and keep fighting!


Lea (no uh) | Monday September 7, 2009 09:12 am 58
In response to PriscillaQOB @ 57

Education is the area where Obama has really disappointed me. He’s just continuing the blame the teachers game, substituting charters for vouchers. There are just too many studies that show the effect that out-of-school factors have on student achievement…poor nutrition, lack of medical care, inferior housing, unstable home life, etc. Factors over which teachers have NO control. Help us teach…don’t threaten us. Teachers are not in it for the money.


300SDL | Monday September 7, 2009 09:19 am 59
In response to PriscillaQOB @ 57

You are sure welcome. Think back when you were in school to the teachers who inspired and enlightened you with their unselfish giving. Did you forget them? Of course not. But did you forget those who just showed up, did their job, and left? Sure—and deservedly so.

While you may not see it now—you are making the difference to your students through your generosity and leadership. In my estimation, that’s one of the very best things we can teach our children as they will, consciously or not, imitate the role models that are offered to them. That is why what you do is so important, for without people like you, your students may never personally see a positive role model in their entire lives.


CarolynU | Monday September 7, 2009 09:24 am 60

Oh excellent post Christy. Digraceful statistics – 1,000,000 homeless school kids!


tejanarusa | Monday September 7, 2009 11:35 am 61
In response to barbara @ 3

Yeah – and I love the reason – supposedly there’s “been no inflation,” so no COLA.

Thought about that in the supermarket yesterday, when I put back my preferred brand of bread because it’s gone up again; 15 cent increase on my fave cold cereal (which had a shelf sticker bragging it’s price is “only” 2.95), etc., etc.
I’m now stretching the pricey cat food by mixing in a supermarket brand – no ill effects yet, and saves me 2/3 of the monthly cost. (why aren’t I switching entirely? Because I remember the difference in their health – and the vet bills – after switching from store food to pricey brand-much much less illness, for real).

Oh, yes, we live in the greatest country with the greatest food and medical care in the world./s
Starting to wonder about retiring to Mexico…although that has its downside, too.


tejanarusa | Monday September 7, 2009 11:38 am 62
In response to ShotoJamf @ 16

Oh, good – tried 3 bookstores looking for it, all gone.


Margot | Monday September 7, 2009 12:19 pm 63
In response to SouthernDragon @ 7

Amen.
This is from an article from the Santa Fe New Mexican:

Elizabeth Bunker, a counselor at César Chávez Elementary School, where 85 percent of the almost 600 children live below poverty level, sees the results of the daily struggle. Many of the kids only eat when they are at school, she said. More than once she’s run down to Walmart to buy a child a decent set of clothes.

“We have three families that just had their electricity turned off,” Bunker said. “One dad had lost a job, one was injured on the job and the other — we’re not sure yet what happened. What scares us is we always find out about these things by accident. Suddenly a kid isn’t doing his homework. When you get him alone, it turns out he couldn’t do it because the electricity was turned off.”


twinkie1cat | Monday September 7, 2009 02:20 pm 64
In response to PriscillaQOB @ 4

It is pretty standard for teachers to have to buy supplies for their students. In fact I have heard the average amount a teacher buys is about $500 worth each year. Of course this is especially hard on the baby teachers who are just out of college and might not get a full pay check for two months and don’t yet have a stash! That is why teachers hoard materials. Even if you get a supply budget it could be months before the materials come in. Before Katrina I had already bought $250 worth of supplies for my students because the previous year I had not gotten any supply money. Then it all got blown away. Even at a ritzy, over equipped school where most of the kids came from Republican families they did not want to come up off of the computer cartridges!

I not only bought stuff for my kids, but I always kept a few extra packs of pencils and notebook paper for kids from other classes who did not have any. My church has a school supply drive for a transitional ministry for women coming out of prison who have children and kids who stay at the local battered women’s shelter. This year we were somewhat short because, like most congregations, ours has people whose incomes have dropped. So some of us have already started collecting supplies for next year.

The real tragedy is that there are kids who are living in environments that they have no control over, shelters, cars, crowded up with other families, with adults who party late at night. I once knew a high school boy who slept on a couch in the living room of a crack house. Eventually he quit school, found a job and got a room.

Perhaps the worst of all is families where mama is trying! She worked two minimum wage part time jobs, one in the morning, one in the evening and had 3 children, a preschooler, a pre-k and a 4th grader. The 4th grader could not read, write, or do math. She appeared to be learning disabled but not retarded, but no one had bothered to test her for special education. When school let out in the afternoon she brought the pre-k to tutoring with her. Afterward little Yolanda picked up the preschooler at HeadStart, took them home, ate the dinner mama had left and got them a bath and to bed. She was only 9. But there was no one to help her with her homework because Mama had to ride the bus and did not get home until 10PM. And there was no extended family to help because grandma was on drugs and her old man had molested Yolanda.

This is our future generation. These are the people who will work in our tourist industry, our nursing homes, and our restaurants. These are the poor children. Maybe if we treat and educate them better they can become teachers, nurses, bankers, electricians, plumbers and mechanics instead. Or at least they won’t be prison inmates and drug dealers and can hold a job at Walmart.


twinkie1cat | Monday September 7, 2009 02:32 pm 65
In response to Margot @ 63

I have known several who were staying home alone while their mother was in jail! Kids at one school where I worked would sneak back in at lunchtime when they were suspended. A ten year old special education child sold drugs just barely off campus. He later killed a man at the age of 12. One family was eating on newspapers on the floor because mama had sold the furniture for drugs. A few were lucky if they got grits for supper because what the school served was all the food they received. That is why the summer feeding programs are so necessary. A lot of kids the only food they get is what the school gives them so the churches and community groups have to take care of them. I wonder what the kids who live in the country do. City kids know exactly where the food is in the summer. Little children have no shame. They love their teachers and will tell it all. But the foster care system is no better than what the kids have with their natural families. A lot of foster parents abuse the kids or are just in it for the money and by the time they reach their teens the children are totally warped. I know three brothers who were brought up in foster care. One is in and out of jail. One is in prison. The oldest one sells drugs. They were probably in 40 foster homes.


twinkie1cat | Monday September 7, 2009 02:44 pm 66
In response to Lea (no uh) @ 53

Sometimes it gets even worse! The winter-only homeless shelters in Atlanta would close about a week before testing, so the kids had to deal with moving and testing. Then the family shelters would not take boys over 13 so young adolescents had to deal with dangerous men’s shelters or stay in the streets. Some mothers would sleep in their cars rather than go to a family shelter without their sons.


twinkie1cat | Monday September 7, 2009 03:08 pm 67
In response to PriscillaQOB @ 55

The test scores always get blamed on the teachers even though we are not even fully in charge of our own classrooms. But how can an untrained Teach for America be, in any way, better than a real teacher with an education degree. The only thing they have to offer is youth and enthusiasm. Youth means you tend to be flighty, easily frustrated, and unsettled. Enthusiasm is a good quality but not essential, dedication is much more important. Our children, especially our disadvantaged children, need wise, knowledgeable teachers who are rock steady and know their job, which takes 3 years to learn (5 for some kinds of special ed.).

I like and voted for Obama, but neither he nor Arne Duncan are teachers and he should have chosen one to lead the Department of Education. Doctors run the AMA. Lawyers run the State Bar. Plumbers head the Plumbers Union. But why don’t teachers run education It makes me furious. Now they are going so far as to give schools principals who are not teachers. How can someone lead teachers who does not speak “educationese” and a second, equally important language called “special ed.” ( I can lose a regular teacher in a couple of sentences. What could I do to a principal who was not even a teacher?)

I guess because we are mostly women there is a strong undercurrent that we are incapable in high level positions. We still have not had a female president. But the thing is, Georgia had a governor a few years back who was a teacher. (Plus the State Superintendent, also a teacher, recently won a million dollars on Smarter than a 5th grader.) Even though he was a conservative, Zell Miller was first a teacher. Pay shot up and the schools improved. I don’t think there is a child in Georgia who goes to school in a raggedy building because the lottery is strictly for education and certain programs in education. Just as you would not go to a lawyer for a heart bypass, you don’t go to a businessman, community activist or lawyer for an education. I love what Obama is trying to do with health care, but he needs to find a teacher to head up the Department of Education.


300SDL | Monday September 7, 2009 03:10 pm 68
In response to twinkie1cat @ 64

“This is our future generation.”

Well said. Perhaps we need to consider what kind of world we will be leaving them as we define the legacy of our generation. Because that is how others will remember us for all time.


Sorry but the comments are closed on this post
Sunday Cuppa
Teach Our Children Well

Close