Sunday Cuppa

Color me intrigued by the potential of this film in asking really important questions about life and internal debates.  And possibly shedding some needed light on a very shrouded religious sect’s history:

The project was initiated by a member of Opus Dei, is partly produced and financed by the group’s members and has enlisted an Opus Dei priest to consult on the set. News of the project has set off criticism among some former Opus Dei members that the movie will be little more than propaganda for the organization. But Mr. Joffé, in the first interview he has given about the film, said that he had been given complete creative control and that Opus Dei never had any influence on the project.

He ditched the script he was originally given, he said, because he did not want to make what he called a “biopic” about Escrivá’s life. But, he added, he was intrigued by Escrivá’s ideas about the power of forgiveness and the capacity of every human being for sainthood. Opus Dei — the name is Latin for work of God — teaches that ordinary work can be a path to sanctity if the believer maintains a demanding regimen of religious practices intended to achieve holiness.

And yet? I’m skeptical about the "full creative control" from financial backers.

Does that smack of set up for contrived public protest and victimhood if the film isn’t sufficiently reverential of its subject to anyone else?

Anyone heard anything about this film? 

I loved the shades of gray and bleak honesty of Joffe’s prior work in "The Killing Fields."  Would love to see some of that on this subject matter, good or ill, as well.

 
21 Responses to "Sunday Cuppa"
demi | Sunday August 23, 2009 06:04 am 1

I haven’t heard anything about this film, but after reading your link, I’m also intrigued. I don’t go to the movies very often. Actually, it’s been years, but I would go see this one. I know that a lot of folks are just turned off by religion and I can understand why, especially with the fundamentalist influence on government.
I’m reading a book right now by retired Episcopalian Bishop John Shelby Spong, Jesus for the Non-Religious: Recovering the divine at the heart of the human.
He says in the book’s preface “Dietrich Bonhoeffer once called on the Christian world to separate Christianity from religion…will find a way through the human Jesus but beyond the confines of religion….”.
I just find this kind of thinking so inspirational.


foothillsmike | Sunday August 23, 2009 07:10 am 2

Morning Christy, Just a flyby to say hi. My son will be visiting on his way to the AF base in Albuquerque for a refresher course. Will be great to see him but have chores to get done before his arrival.
I grew up Catholic including catholic school, did a stint attending Episcopal church (catholic light). I have since developed a contempt for the old testament and don’t care to have anything to do with any organization that professes it.


RevBev | Sunday August 23, 2009 08:00 am 3
In response to foothillsmike @ 2

“Any organization” would include Temples and Synagogues…too bad. The lesson/wisdom of the Old Testament/Hebrew Bible is at least in the Moses liberation story, language of our civil rights movement and in the lessons for justice/focus on the community in the Prophets. I think the Exodus story is about as good as it gets…


foothillsmike | Sunday August 23, 2009 08:31 am 4

And in a truce the enemies were convinced that if they were circumcized that all would be copesthetic. After this they were all given wine and fell asleep at which time they were slaughtered while they slept yea Gawd.


Adie | Sunday August 23, 2009 08:39 am 5

OT with apologies, but i wanted some place to tuck this ideagerm. Desperation breeds nonsense in my brain but – hey – nothing else has worked so far, so…. going on the record as it were, I sent the following today.

Dear Senator Voinovich:

As you approach your announced retirement from the U. S. Senate, I beg you to consider a change in your personal strategy for participating in the governance of this country.

I would greatly appreciate and honor you if you would follow Senator Sherrod Brown’s lead in choosing how you will vote in the coming months.

The current and looming crisis in health care is critical to our future. So are a number of deeply disturbing environmental crises. And of course your usual preferred topic of concern, economic issues.

Many others in your party have chosen to fight tooth and nail against all things favored by those across the aisle. Yet such a strategy does your party absolutely no good politically. (consult any reliable poll however you wish, for verification)

The current Republican Party strategy of “NO!” to all things Democratic is heartless, hideously misguided, and bordering on malfeasance, in my view.

Our nation, and the world, need you personally to step up and follow an honorable path of governance. Senator Brown has shown he is utterly committed to doing so without animosity or callous disregard for others. Please, please follow his lead, even if quietly, only with your votes on all upcoming critical issues.

Trumpeting about fiscal responsibility is no answer in and of itself, any more. We need more from you in the last months of your term. Compassion and a broad view would be extremely gratifying and appreciated.

In case you wonder, neither I nor any of our family have any connection whatsoever with Brown, other than having great respect for him as a serious, gifted legislator.

Thank you in advance for considering this simple plea.

Follow Sherrod Brown.

Sincerely,

[adie]

[-um- as i preview this, the date at the top of my comment says Sept. 10 2007 at 10:32 am!?! is FDL having a hissyfit or am I loopie?]


Adie | Sunday August 23, 2009 08:41 am 6

ah. nevermind. still,…… weird system ya got there Redd and mods. heh.

and, yes, i did try refresh but the date was still off until the actual filing.

testing…. testing…. *g*


Adie | Sunday August 23, 2009 08:45 am 7

egad. i feel like a dawg that just buried a bone in an otherwise pristine back yard. i’m leaving. honest. apologies and cheers with that topic there pups.
*clutching robe a little tighter*


RevBev | Sunday August 23, 2009 09:44 am 8
In response to Adie @ 7

Great letter, dawg….Good luck


Elliott | Sunday August 23, 2009 09:54 am 9

Hadn’t heard a thing about this movie. Should be revealing and hopefully it will shine the light back on this group of -imo- weirdos.


Elliott | Sunday August 23, 2009 10:09 am 10

And what a gorgeous birdie!


Adie | Sunday August 23, 2009 12:04 pm 11
In response to RevBev @ 8

Oh, Thanks Bev at #8. That means a lot. To know him is to understand the strange lil’ dance it takes to try to poke him just hard enuf to cause a coupl’a brain cells to jiggle in their sockets, without causing him to run back under the couch again for the duration. sigh.

And YES, the birdie is absolutely gorgeous. Almost blue enough to suit me. heh. That’s no photo-shop folks. Enjoy.

p.s., is “Reply” function kaput for anyone other than me? Weird vapours over the Lake some times these days. Gee. I wonder why that would be.

Apologies to George Carlin: All you tall guys: behind the trees. All you short guys: behind the bushes. Hey You wid da beads! Outta here!


RevBev | Sunday August 23, 2009 12:21 pm 12
In response to Adie @ 11

Reply OK here. I was checking back in also b/c this is special music day for
demi…Demi, if you come by, let us know how it went. I took a rest day myself….not feeling so well. SO had some sunday down time


laurastrand | Sunday August 23, 2009 02:26 pm 13

Dear Christie, I simply was incapable of focusing on the subject as the Lovely Yellow-legged guy was overwhelming my senses . . . . .


sjelly | Sunday August 23, 2009 02:39 pm 14

Besides being amazed by the honeycreeper’s dazzling beauty, I’m amused that its namers found its yellow-leggedness to be its most remarkable feature.


chetnolian | Sunday August 23, 2009 03:27 pm 15

Not quite ot.

The powers of forgiveness and compassion seem sadly lacking at the moment in the US of A.

Everyone from the President down is ganging up to condemn the Justice Minister of my old country Scotland, for carrying out his job and releasing Meghrabi, on compassionate grounds just before he dies, in accordance with a settled provision of Scottish law.

Just because the US prefers to execute murderers, a practice we gave up years ago as barbaric, doesn’t mean it has any right to force us to be lacking in compassion. And of course I feel for the families of the victims, but a grown-up justice system is about more than simple revenge.


Ruffian | Sunday August 23, 2009 04:37 pm 16
In response to chetnolian @ 15

I am thinking from this you are living in Scotland? How often has ths been done?

(I loved listenng to the news sories interviewing Scots who actually believe in the compassion and mercy from the Bible!)


MrWhy | Sunday August 23, 2009 07:40 pm 17

Slightly OT. Peter Baker at the NYT has a story – Most of Obama’s Top Appointees Are Not in Place – that doesn’t mention Dawn Johnsen.


justiceputnam | Sunday August 23, 2009 08:58 pm 18

If Ed Wood was able to take Baptist money and make a “great” movie like Plan 9 from Outer Space, then maybe Joffe can take Opus Dei money and make a movie completely unlike what the Cardinal Sinners expect.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0052077/


justiceputnam | Sunday August 23, 2009 09:01 pm 19

Weird, only the link showed on my previous post. What I wrote earlier was…

If Ed Wood could take Baptist money and make Plan 9 From Outer Space, then maybe Joffe can tale Cardinal money and make a movie completely unlike what the Holy See expects.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0052077/


justiceputnam | Sunday August 23, 2009 09:03 pm 20

ok, even more weird… I’ll try it w/out the link this time…

What I wrote earlier was…

If Ed Wood could take Baptist money and make Plan 9 From Outer Space, then maybe Joffe can take Cardinal money and make a movie completely unlike what the Holy See expects.


chetnolian | Monday August 24, 2009 05:54 am 21
In response to Ruffian @ 16

Probably too late, I went to bed in the UK, but the answer in Scotland since 2000 is 30 applications and 23 releases. So it is not unusual. One of the strong criteria is an expectation of having no moe re than three months to live.

I was brought up in Scotland but don’t live there any more. By the way, I was in Lockerbie on the day after the crash, so I probably have a better undestanding of its enormity than most who are commenting.


Sorry but the comments are closed on this post

Close